The Agricultural Policy of the EU has been proceeding to be one of the mostly debatable areas of the Union since the foundation of the Common Agricultural Policy in the 1960s. Various standpoints exist concerning this controversial policy. Division of individuals into either the exponents or the opponents of this sectoral regulation can arguably be contingent on their relation to it. Opposing perspectives on the same topic draws attention to ascertain in what respects and whether the CAP may be considered an integral part of the EU or to the detriment of the Union, which is in turn also the focal question of this work. This paper seeks to address the conflicting attitudes related to the EU Agriculture Policy and to examine to what extent this legal instrument deserves to be condemned or commended.