This paper explores the impact of social status on perceptions of the reservation system in South India, focusing on four key states: Telangana, Karnataka, Andhra Pradesh, and Tamil Nadu. The study uses a survey-descriptive research design, incorporating a sample of 400 respondents selected through quota sampling, with 100 participants from each state. A mixed-methods approach combines qualitative techniques such as non-participant observation, and in-depth interviews with quantitative methods, including semi-structured interview schedules and statistical analyses (chi-square and ANOVA tests). The findings reveal significant variations in the rationale behind support for reservation policies among different social groups (EWS, BC, SC, OC), with each group citing different reasons, including historical deprivation, economic concerns, and physical weakness. The study also finds significant differences in perceptions regarding the impact of reservations on access to education, employment, healthcare, government administration, and other key societal areas. Notably, social status was found to influence perceptions of financial inclusion, discrimination, and societal unrest, while areas such as social acceptability and scientific temper showed no significant variation across groups. Additionally, a Chi-Square test revealed diverse opinions across demographic groups regarding the need for more flexible reservation policies, emphasizing the need for policymakers to consider these varying perspectives when discussing potential reforms to the reservation system. This research highlights the complexity of the reservation system’s impact and underscores the importance of considering social status in policy evaluations.